The Dark Underbelly of the Lottery

Whether it’s buying a Powerball ticket or a quickie scratch-off, many of us participate in the lottery with some degree of expectation that we might win. After all, someone has to win. But there’s a dark underbelly to the exercise: the truth is that odds are stacked against us.

The chances of winning a prize are calculated by multiplying the number of tickets sold by the probability that each ticket matches the numbers randomly chosen. The higher the ticket sales, the better your chance of winning. The smallest prizes are awarded to those who match just one number, while the largest awards go to those who match five. There are also special categories for a few rarer combinations, such as matching the three-digit numbers in a winning sequence (1-2-3-4-5-6).

State lotteries, which are subsidized by government revenues and operated with a private monopoly, provide a model of how the general public can be seduced into paying taxes for services they don’t want but can’t afford. They are also a classic case of public policy being made piecemeal, incrementally, with little or no overall perspective. The result is that specific constituencies develop their own interests and pressures, including convenience store operators (who sell the most tickets); lottery suppliers (heavy contributions by them to state political campaigns are often reported); teachers (in those states where lottery proceeds are earmarked for education); state legislators (who quickly grow accustomed to the additional revenue); and more.

In its earliest days, the lottery was used to raise money for a variety of public purposes. Benjamin Franklin sponsored a lottery to raise funds for cannons to defend Philadelphia during the American Revolution, and public lotteries were used for many other projects, including the building of the British Museum, the repair of bridges, and several American colleges, such as Harvard, Dartmouth, and Yale. Privately organized lotteries were also popular as a means to sell products or properties for more than they could be sold for in a regular sale.

Most modern lotteries are run by the state, with each state legislating a monopoly for itself and then establishing a state agency or public corporation to manage it. These agencies typically begin operations with a small number of relatively simple games, but due to pressure for increased revenues they quickly expand the range and complexity of their offerings.

Some states are also part of multi-state lotteries, where the winners are divided among a group of participating states. This helps increase jackpots and attract more players, but the system is not without its problems. In addition, studies show that lottery play varies by socio-economic factors, with men playing more than women; blacks and Hispanics playing more than whites; the young playing less than the middle-aged; and those with higher levels of education playing more than those with lower educational achievement. This sort of segmentation of the population by demographic is not unusual for state-run lotteries, but it is a reminder that there are real and important implications in the decisions that lottery officials make.